| Year | Winner | Runner Up | Score | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1991 | Finch Hill A | Nobles Park B | 6-2 | Marown |
| 1992 | Finch Hill A - (2) | Marown A | 7-1 | Port Erin |
| 1993 | Port St Mary A | Finch Hill B | 6-2 | Peel |
| 1994 | Port St Mary A - (2) | Port Erin A | 4-4 | Castletown |
| 1995 | Douglas A | Port St Mary B | 7-1 | Peel |
| 1996 | Douglas A - (2) | South Ramsey A | 5-3 | Marown |
| 1997 | Onchan B | South Ramsey A | 5-3 | Finch Hill |
| 1998 | Douglas A - (3) | Port Erin A | 5-3 | Marown |
| 1999 | South Ramsey A | Finch Hill B | 5-3 | Peel |
| 2000 | Nobles Mixed A | North Ramsey A | 7-1 | Peel |
| 2001 | Nobles Mixed A - (2) | South Ramsey | 6-2 | Peel |
| 2002 | North Ramsey A | Finch Hill A | 6-3 | Peel |
| 2003 | North Ramsey A - (2) | Onchan B | 5-4 | Peel |
| 2004 | South Ramsey A - (2) | Onchan B | 5-4 | Peel |
| 2005 | South Ramsey A - (3) | Finch Hill B | 5-4 | Ballaugh |
| 2006 | Port Erin A | Port St Mary B | 5-4 | Castletown |
| 2007 | Port Erin A - (2) | Onchan B | 5-4 | Peel |
| 2008 | Nobles Park A | Onchan B | 6-3 | Port St Mary |
| 2009 | Onchan B - (2) | North Ramsey B | 7-2 | Marown |
| 2010 | Ballaugh B | Onchan B | 7-2 | Marown |
| 2011 | Port Erin A - (3) | Onchan B | 6-3 | Castletown |
| 2012 | Nobles Mixed A - (3) | Port Erin A | 6-3 | ??? |
| 2013 | Onchan B - (3) | Nobles Park A | 7-2 (176-136) | Finch Hill |
| 2014 | North Ramsey B | Onchan B | 7-2 (177-150) | South Ramsey |
| 2015 | Finch Hill A | Peel Sunset B | 5-4 (159-154) | Castletown |
| 2016 | Port Erin A - (4) | Onchan B | 5-4 (150-149) | Finch Hill |
| 2017 | Finch Hill A - (2) | Onchan B | 6-3 169-157 | Nobles 1 |
| 2018 | Port Erin A - (5) | Peel Sunset B | 6-3 160-147 | Marown |
